Equipment · Article

Glass, plastic or stainless: choosing a fermenter by material

Vessel material changes weight, cleaning, visibility and how careful you have to be. Here is what the catalogue records and what it does not.

Updated 2026-11-21 · 4 min read · FermentLab

A fermenter is the one piece of equipment the batch sits in for weeks, so the material matters more than the price difference suggests. The catalogue records vessel material for every record that has one.

It records nothing about durability, oxygen permeability or ease of cleaning, so those have to come from the manufacturer.

Plastic: light, cheap, scratchable

Plastic buckets and carboys are the standard starting point. They are light, inexpensive and let you see fermentation if they are translucent.

The weakness is scratches, which harbour microbes. Replace a scratched plastic fermenter rather than trying to sanitise around it.

Glass: inert and heavy

Glass does not scratch and does not hold odours, which makes it a good choice for wine and for anything delicate. It is also heavy and breakable.

A glass carboy full of beer is a two-person lift with a handle. Plan for that before buying one.

Stainless: the long-term option

Stainless steel is durable, easy to clean and can be used for both beer and wine without carrying flavours across. It is the most expensive of the three.

If you already know you will keep brewing, stainless is the one that does not get replaced. The temperature control guide covers the related question of holding a set point.

Whichever you choose, buy one with a tap if the batch size is larger than a couple of gallons. Lifting and siphoning a full carboy is the most common way homebrewers hurt their backs.

Look at the lid and airlock as part of the material decision. A lid that does not seal turns a fermenter into a slow leak, and a wide-mouth opening is much easier to clean than a narrow neck.

The buying guides behind this article

More articles from FermentLab